Archaeologists assess Tut tragedy

NBC's Kate Snow reports on the damage done to Egypt's antiquities.

Update for 4:30 p.m. ET Jan. 31: Despite the best efforts of the Egyptian army and a human shield, some of the ancient treasures inside the century-old Egyptian Museum were damaged during a brief wave of looting, authorities in Cairo say. Among the damaged artifacts are two pharaonic mummies and a priceless statuette from the tomb of Tutankhamun.

The country's top archaeologist, Zahi Hawass, described the damage in a series of statements, including an update that was posted to his blog on Sunday. He said looters ransacked the museum's gift shop and went on to vandalize authentic treasures as well. More than a dozen display cases were broken into, including one that contained the Tut statuette. "The criminals found a statue of the king on a panther, broke it, and threw it on the floor," Hawass wrote. "I am very thankful that all of the antiquities that were damaged in the museum can be restored, and the tourist police caught all of the criminals that broke into it."

The looters scattered pieces of the mummies across the museum floor — and judging by the photographs that were released Monday (graphic content below), restoring those relics will be challenging to say the least.


Roger Wood/CORBIS

A figurine from Tutankhamun's tomb shows the boy-king riding a panther.

Al Jazeera via EloquentPeasant.com

A video frame from Al Jazeera shows what appears to be the panther in pieces, with the figurine of Tutankhamun missing.

Based on video footage that was shot inside the museum, some observers suggest that other treasures from Tut's tomb may have been damaged as well. Margaret Maitland, an Egyptologist at Oxford University in England, suggested that at least one other gilded statuettes of the boy-king pictures may have been broken off its pedestal.

This one shows Tut standing on a boat with a harpoon at the ready:

Robert Harding World Imagery/Corbis

A wooden statuette shows the gilded figure of Tutankhamun standing on a boat, holding a harpoon.

APTV via msnbc.com

This video frame from the looted Egyptian Museum shows what appears to be the boat, with the Tut figure broken off.

Maitland also pointed to another video showing a wooden block with the broken-off feet still attached. At first, she assumed that this suggested yet another statuette of a standing Tut was snapped off, but later analysis made it seem more likely that these were the broken-off feet from the "Tut on a panther" statuette. Check out Maitland's blog posting at the Eloquent Peasant for those comparisons.

Hawass said two mummies in the museum were destroyed, with their heads ripped off. In one of the most upsetting pictures from the museum, shown below, the mummies' heads and bones can be seen spread across the floor.

AP

This photo was taken early Saturday in the Egyptian Museum and made available on Monday. Parts of unidentified mummies, including the heads, are seen damaged on the floor.

Over the weekend, experts wondered whether two mummies may have been the mortal remains of Tut's great-grandparents, Yuya and Tuya. That surmise was based on a comparison of a gilded mummy case seen in the video with photographs of the case that was laid over Tuya's mummy. Discovery News' Rossella Lorenzi focused on that angle.

On Monday, however, Aidan Dodson, an Egyptologist from the University of Bristol, reported that the mummies were unlikely to be those of Yuya and Tuya. As explained in an update from Maitland, the mummy case had been separated from Tuya's mummy and was being exhibited in the museum by itself.

Maitland noted that two more ruined displays matched up with well-known items from Egypt's antiquity: an array of soldier figurines and a wooden model boat from the tomb of Mesehti, a provincial governor during the 11th or 12th Dynasty (roughly 2025 to 1700 B.C.). Here are pictures showing those damaged artifacts:

MSNBC TV

A video grab shows damage done to a display case that apparently contains an array of soldier figurines from the tomb of Mesehti, a provincial governor from the 11th or 12th Dynasty.

MSNBC TV

An armed security guard stands watch next to a display case containing a damaged model boat from the tomb of Mesehti.

In his blog posting, Hawass provided specific information about the Tut-on-a-panther statuette (which is actually one of two similar statuettes from the tomb), but not about the other items that appear to be damaged in the video. Why not? It could be because Hawass is still trying to get all the facts of the story straight, or because he's reluctant to publicize the full extent of the damage at this time. It's also possible that some of the items shown in the video are display-case replicas or gift-shop knock-offs rather than the real things.

In any case, Hawass sees the damage and looting as a national tragedy.

"My heart is broken and my blood is boiling," he wrote. "I feel that everything I have done in the last nine years has been destroyed in one day, but all the inspectors, young archaeologists, and administrators, are calling me from sites and museums all over Egypt to tell me that they will give their life to protect our antiquities."

The good news
That's the good news about the saga of Egypt's endangered heritage. The current chaos in Cairo easily could have left all the priceless artifacts at the Egyptian Museum, including Tutankhamun's 3,300-year-old golden death mask, vulnerable to widespread looting. After all, that's how the situation played out for Baghdad's national museum in 2003 after the fall of Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein.

It didn't happen that way in Cairo because of the high-mindedness of the government as well as its critics.

When fire broke out on Friday night at the ruling party's headquarters, Khaled Youssef, an Egyptian film director who has made movies critical of government policies, issued an urgent call on the Al Arabiya television channel: "I am calling on the Egyptian army to head instantly to the Egyptian Museum. There is a fire right next to it in the party headquarters," he said in a report relayed by Reuters.

As the fire raged, would-be thieves started entering the grounds surrounding the museum, The Associated Press reported. But other young men, some armed with truncheons taken from the police, formed a protective human chain outside the museum's main gates. "I'm standing here to defend and to protect our national treasure," one of the men, a 40-year-old engineer named Farid Saad, told AP.

AP quoted 26-year-old Ahmed Ibrahim as saying that it was important to guard the museum because it has "5,000 years of our history. If they steal it, we'll never find it again."

Another defender at the gates pleaded with the crowd not to let the looters in, shouting, "We are not like Baghdad!"

Finally, four of the army's armored vehicles took up posts outside the museum. Soldiers surrounded the building and moved inside.

AP said the soldiers rounded up would-be looters who made it onto the museum grounds and lined them up in a row. As the soldiers corralled one man toward the line, crowds outside the fence shouted, "Thief, thief!" A couple of the troops hit the man with the butts of their rifles and sat him down with others who were apparently caught inside the gates.

The army and the people are continuing to keep watch on the museum and its riches amid Egypt's crisis.

Treasures galore
Tut's golden mask is arguably the most precious of the museum's treasures — so precious that authorities will no longer let it travel out of the country, even though many other artifacts from Tut's time are currently on the road. (I had the chance to see the mask in Seattle in 1978 during the "Treasures of Tutankhamun" exhibit.) The 109-year-old museum serves as the central repository for the riches from Tut's tomb, which was discovered by Egyptologist Howard Carter in the Valley of the Kings in 1922. But there's lots more to protect. The highlights range from monumental statues of Amenhotep III and his family to Roman-era gold treasures dug up from Egypt's Western Desert.

Amr Nabil / AP file

The golden mask of Tutankhamun is the best-known treasure at Cairo's Egyptian Museum.

Elizabeth Bartman, president of the Archaeological Institute of America, told me she was heartened to hear that the Egyptian people were so keen to protect their cultural heritage.

"If the reports about the human cordon around the museum are true, that's a very moving thing for me," she told me. "They regard their archaeological finds as so precious that it's worth their lives to protect them."

University of Pennsylvania archaeologist C. Brian Rose, the institute's past president, wasn't surprised by the reports.

"It's not possible to plan for the future unless one understands the past, and I think this is something that all Egyptians understand very well," Rose told me. "There's a great respect for the cultural heritage of Egypt — shared, I think, by I would say nearly all Egyptians. I hope that respect will keep the archaeological sites and museums safe from any harm during this period of conflict."

Even if the protesters and government forces share that respect for the museum's antiquities, the situation could still lead to unintended and unwelcome consequences.

"Especially with Egypt being such a dry place — they have all these organic materials, they have textiles, they have ancient food, they have lots of wooden items — fire is a very scary proposition," Bartman said. "Let's just keep our fingers crossed that the museums are not going to be caught in the crossfire."

More tales from the museums:

And other sagas of endangered antiquities:


Join the Cosmic Log community by clicking the "like" button on our Facebook page or by following msnbc.com science editor Alan Boyle as b0yle on Twitter. To learn more about Alan Boyle's book about Pluto and the search for planets, check out the website for "The Case for Pluto."

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4 5 ... 9

If these antiques were related to muslims/muhammad/allah/khomenie/koran/hussein/mosques, there would have been a.... well, you know what.

BUT it is not,

So! nobody cares except the historians. But, even most of them are Islamic appeasers.

  • 1 vote
Reply#62 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:35 PM EST

Not everything is seen or accepted or viewed through the eyes of religion alone. Regardless of your belief, or that of others, these articles are historic, beautiful and some may have had religious significance. Don't say no one cares - because historians and others look for, care for and study ancient civilizations does not make them "Islamic appeasers" as you have stated.

  • 2 votes
#62.1 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:03 PM EST

Well said!

    #62.2 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:43 PM EST
    Reply

    It makes me sick to see those wooden objects damaged. I really can't believe that security failed, and it must be corrected at all costs. There is no replacement or repair possible with these priceless things. I was there in person about 10 years ago and it is amazing. If they have to they should post machine guns at the entrance.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#63 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:35 PM EST

    Not sure why they would want to loot things that are of such value to them as a country but perhaps it is not that meaningful to them. How sad that they need to be guarded from their own citizens.

    So when they stop looting and destroying things what will be left from them/will they have found a better way? They chant that they want Mubarak gone but what do they want then????? They do not seem thrilled with the anarchy either.

    Same thing happened in Iran though in 79/I had lived there prior to the revolt and had occasion to return very briefly after and it was a shame the damage that had been done to some of the beautiful artifacts and treasures. Swimming pools in large hotels were drained and destroyed along with beautiful architecture.

    Such a waste/hope they get what they desire but they should be careful what they wish for

      Reply#64 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:42 PM EST

      And Zahi Hawass was last week demanding that Germany return the bust of Nefertiti, announcing, among other things, that the statue would be better protected in Egyptian hands... Well, Hawass, I'd say Germany was right, at this time, to deny your request.

      • 2 votes
      Reply#65 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:45 PM EST

      We did not get help for our revolution ans they should be able to get their revolution and build what they want. America needs to keep their nose out of it.

        Reply#66 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:47 PM EST

        Actually, we got loads of help. Mostly from France. Do your homework.

          #66.1 - Sun Jan 30, 2011 6:20 PM EST
          Reply

          If this kind of disturbance keeps up, I hope they do move the Tutankamun artifacts to a safer location--even out of the country if necessary. These treasures are too valuable a link to the historical past to allow them to be further damaged or even destroyed in the next civilian uprising.

          • 1 vote
          Reply#67 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:49 PM EST

           This is why Western countries should not return Egyptian artifacts from their own museums back to the Egyptian government.  Hawass be damned, he can kiss my arse.

          • 2 votes
          Reply#68 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:51 PM EST

          hawass is like the kid who wants to play marbles, as long as he owns all the marbles & doesn't have to share. he also tries to bully other countries by limiting their ability to do archaeological digs in egypt. he wants the rosetta stone & the bust of nefertiti returned. he acts like they were stolen. they weren't. both items were legally obtained by the museums. he has a convenient habbit of trying to rewrite the past & make foreigners the villains. many of the egytian pieces were saved because they were put into musuems. if they hadn't been, they would have been sold on the egyptian black market & would be in private collections. never to be seen by the public.

          seeing pictures of the damaged items makes me cringe. i wish they would say which 2 mummies were destroyed. i'll have to check the website for kmt magazine. hopefully they'll have some news posted. i hope.

            #68.1 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:02 PM EST
            Reply

            Modern Egyptians (the looters who destroyed these artifacts) are not the descendants of the Ancient Egyptians. That's why they don't care, and that's why Western countries should not return any Ancient Egyptian artifacts. It would be like giving an ancient Native American artifact to Rush Limbaugh.

            • 3 votes
            Reply#69 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:55 PM EST

            Rush would take good care of it.

              #69.1 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:04 PM EST
              Reply

              Wasn't it last week that it was announced that the tombs would be closed - to protect them from the elements - humidity, mold, etc. Hopefully what is stored or on display in the museum(s) will be safe. Hopefully whatever was damaged and/or destroyed in the attack on Friday was only a duplicate. Very sad.

              • 3 votes
              Reply#70 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:56 PM EST

               COMPLETE GARBAGE! And they wonder why we do not trust them. They even distroy their our history, it's all about me!!!!! These folks are freakin crazy and why were are at it for those who are in our streets protesting with these monsters, go back to where you came from we have enough crap to deal with in our own Muslim president

              • 1 vote
              Reply#71 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:57 PM EST

              Is ignorance really s solution here? These people are as much monsters as we are. Don't spew hate and ignorance. Just because you don't agree with a person's beliefs, it does not give you the right to attack them.

                #71.1 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:41 PM EST
                Reply

                Who are the looters? Common criminals taking advantage of the current situation? How does this help their cause? Are they not the peaceful protestors? Who are the looters who have stolen and burned and destroyed their land? What respect do they show for their country and fellowman?

                  Reply#72 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 8:59 PM EST

                  those looters are also the ones who would kill us in a heart beat, I say the leader send out the troops and kick the crap of these folks. People hate the leader, but we Americans need to remember this leader is the same one that tried to give us Bin Ladin, but Clinton turned the offer down and that is why we had 9/11.

                  • 1 vote
                  #72.1 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:06 PM EST
                  Reply

                  the people on the street don't care about art. They want their I pad. They don't know their own history they want HDTV!

                    Reply#73 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:01 PM EST

                    Thousands of protestors, and millions not saying much. As for me I'm against anything that's not peaceful.

                      Reply#74 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:04 PM EST

                      There comes a time when talk doesn't work. The only thing these looters understand comes out of the end of a gun. Let everyone know that if anyone tries to loot the museum again they will be shot. I'm sure they had weapons of their own and protecting something that is irreplaceable needs all the protections available including shooting the ones who are doing the looting. Sometimes actions don speak better than words.

                        Reply#75 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:04 PM EST

                        Humans fail to understand the importance of history in times of kaos . . . destruction is all too easy. This is the danger that we all face in the backdrop of what is possible today in the nuclear age. Emotion can destroy everything if we are not careful.

                        Look at what is happening in Egypt and keep it's historical importance in balance with what kaos can do on a world wide scale.

                        We are only the keepers of this samll planet, we all need each other. We must work together to bring order to the streets of Egypt through peaceful cooperation of it's government and that government like all others must realize that no one person is ruler of all they survey . . . the world is too fragile to think otherwise.

                          Reply#76 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:07 PM EST
                          YeenVeenDeleted

                          I am happy to know there are protesters that though they dislike the government and want to remove it for one they feel is best for the people of their country they still have the dignity and respect for themselves and their country to protect it's national treasures against the sensless looting.

                          Looters don't care about the cause, only their own selfish desires to take what isn't theirs.

                          I commend those Egyptians who though protested their government, showed love for country and their history. I loved the quote "We are not Baghdad!", or the engineer "I'm standing here to defend and to protect our national treasure," or the film maker that call the Army who was battling the protesters of which he was one so they would protect the museum that housed their history and heritage. You all have my respect and admiration!

                          • 1 vote
                          Reply#78 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:13 PM EST

                          GOOD! Smash more crap...Now don't delay, MAKE FOR THE HALL OF F-ING RECORDS, and FREE our civilization once and for all!

                            Reply#79 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:15 PM EST

                            It is time for this to end. I think they need to send in the troops now! Go home and give the government a chance to change the situation. I believe they got the message! But, no more violence! Go home!

                              Reply#80 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:21 PM EST

                              Were the looters Egyptian's too? Were the looters part of the protestors? Are they fellow Egyptians?

                                Reply#81 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:25 PM EST

                                Although it will ulitmately be blamed on the US and Israel, they were, indeed, Eyptians.

                                • 1 vote
                                #81.1 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:36 PM EST

                                I'm not really sure how this can be blamed on either the US or Israel. The United States has been an ally to Egypt for a long time.

                                  #81.2 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:38 PM EST

                                  They always find a way.

                                  • 1 vote
                                  #81.3 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 10:01 PM EST
                                  Reply

                                  So sad what's happening in Egypt. This kind of politics have happened in Phillipines, Indonesia, and some country in Africa. Where the ruling government wants to hold "throne" for whole life or too long of time. These "leaders" sitting on a throne enjoying the position and forgeting to work for the people. They are not king and they forgot that they are just "state servants". When these leaders are greedy, inefficient, dishonest than God will show them they actually have nothing, and God (Allah) see what is in their breast or in their mind and what is obvious and what they hide. Sad also that Satan will be in the middle of these people to spark outrageous anger that harm themselves.

                                    Reply#82 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:33 PM EST

                                    If this is how they treat their own artifacts, imagine what will happen when the Arabs take control of East Jerusalem. There will be nothing left!

                                    • 1 vote
                                    Reply#83 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:35 PM EST

                                    This is so sad to me. Thousands upon thousands of years of artifacts that tell of a people's proud and storied past, and those people, in a moment of greed and selfishness broke into the repository of these precious treasure and destroyed some artifacts that i should have liked to look upon one day. Fight for your democracy, and fight for your future, yes, but don't tear down things that have been around for millennia.

                                    • 2 votes
                                    Reply#84 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:36 PM EST

                                    does anyone have feelings for real alive people , all i can see is you guys talking about art affects. OMG what happened to this world , screw art and feed the people

                                      #84.1 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:39 PM EST
                                      Reply

                                      does anyone have feelings for real alive people , all i can see is you guys talking about art affects. OMG what happened to this world , screw art and feed the people

                                        Reply#85 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:39 PM EST

                                        These people are starving and dying! Where are your priorities? these artifacts will be stolen and with any luck sold to wealthy investors. The sale of one small artifact will sustain a family for years. This has happened for centuries when regimes fall the treasures end up scattered to the four winds. Look at the French revolution, Our own Hope diamond was originally part of a massive lue stone called the French Blue.

                                          Reply#86 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:39 PM EST

                                          OMG what are these protesters thinking, treasures from the past their history, and to destory them, not very smart protesters. God be with them.

                                          • 1 vote
                                          Reply#87 - Sat Jan 29, 2011 9:44 PM EST
                                          Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4 5 ... 9
                                          You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                          As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.