
Hanna-Barbera / TriStar / Disney / Pixar
Rosie of "The Jetsons," Johnny 5 from "Short Circuit" and WALL-E are vying for a place in the Robot Hall of Fame.
For the past nine years, the Robot Hall of Fame has relied solely on expert judges to dole out its honors — but this time, the people will get their say. Should Rosie, Johnny 5 or WALL-E join other robotic greats such as R2-D2 and C-3PO in the hall of honor?
This competition isn't just for fictional robots: Internet voting is being conducted to select robot laureates in four categories, from a field of 12 nominees. The idea of factoring in the popular vote is a first for the Robot Hall of Fame, which was created in 2003 by Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh.
"The technology and art of robotics are advancing at an increasingly rapid rate, and so the Robot Hall of Fame also must evolve," Shirley Saldamarco, the hall of fame's director and a faculty member at Carnegie Mellon’s Entertainment Technology Center, said in an announcement kicking off the voting. "As more students, workers and consumers become accustomed to robots, it seems like a natural step to give the public a voice in selecting inductees."
The 12 finalists were nominated by 107 robotics experts, industry leaders and robo-aficionados. You can cast a ballot for one robot in each of the four categories by stepping into this online voting booth, between now and Sept. 30. The popular vote will be factored in with a survey of the robotics experts, on a half-and-half basis, to determine the winners.
The newly chosen robots will be inducted into the Hall of Fame on Oct. 23 at the Carnegie Science Center in Pittsburgh, in conjunction with the RoboBusiness Leadership Summit. "We love robots, and we love to see their inventors and creators get the public recognition they deserve," summit chairman Dan Kara said.
The October induction ceremony also will pay tribute to the 2010 class of Hall of Fame robots: NASA's Spirit and Opportunity rovers, iRobot's Roomba vacuum cleaner, the da Vinci surgical system, the three robots from the film "Silent Running" (Huey, Dewey and Loui) and T-800, the character played by Arnold Schwarzenegger in the "Terminator" film series. To get more information about the ceremony — and to buy tickets at $99 a pop — check out this Eventbrite webpage.
Here's the full list of this year's nominees in the four categories:
Education and consumer robots:
- Aldebaran Robotics' NAO, a 22-inch-tall humanoid that is widely used in education (and robo-soccer games) worldwide.
- iRobot's Create, a programmable robot based on the Roomba vacuum cleaner design.
- VEX Robotics Design System, a kit for designing and building robots for the classroom and for competitions.
Entertainment robots:
- WALL-E, the waste-collecting robot that's the hero of the 2008 animated film of the same name, presented by Pixar and Disney.
- Johnny 5, a prototype military robot that learns to reject destruction and embrace life in the 1986 movie "Short Circuit."
- Rosie, a robotic maid with a mind of her own who took care of her human family on "The Jetsons," a 1960s animated sitcom from Hanna-Barbera.
Industrial and service robots:
- iRobot's Packbot, which takes care of bomb disposal and other dangerous assignments for the U.S. military.
- Kiva System's autonomous warehouse robots, which speed the process of customer orders. (Amazon.com acquired Kiva this year.)
- Jason, a remotely operated vehicle built by Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution to explore the deep ocean.
Research robots:
- BigDog, a four-legged robot that's being developed by Boston Dynamics for the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency to walk, run or climb over rough terrain with heavy loads.
- PR2, a two-armed robot built by Willow Garage that can navigate human environments and has the dexterity to grasp and manipulate objects.
- Robonaut, a dexterous, two-armed robot developed by NASA and GM to help humans work in space. The latest version, Robonaut 2, was delivered to the International Space Station last year.
In addition to the Robot Hall of Fame voting, you can help us continue the tradition of choosing an extra Robot People's Choice for Cosmic Log. Feel free to make your suggestions below, and I'll try to get a sense of the people's will. If you're nominating a People's Choice robot, you should know that all the robots we've mentioned so far are ineligible, as well as the robots that have already been inducted into the Hall of Fame. Here's the list:
- 2010: Spirit and Opportunity; Roomba; da Vinci; Huey, Dewey and Louie; T-800 Terminator.
- 2008: Commander Data, the Raibert Hopper, NavLab 5, Lego Mindstorms robot kit.
- 2006: AIBO, Scara, David (from "A.I."), Maria (from "Metropolis"), Gort (from "The Day the Earth Stood Still").
- 2004: ASIMO, Shakey, Astro Boy, Robby the Robot, C-3PO.
- 2003: HAL 9000, Mars Pathfinder's Sojourner rover, R2-D2, Unimate.
That still leaves plenty of robots to nominate, including the newest star, NASA's Curiosity rover. Feel free to pass along your own People's Choice picks, or take issue with the Hall of Fame selections that have been made so far, by leaving a comment below.
More about robots:
- Gallery: Movie robots to be remembered
- Robots that pop popcorn and make sandwiches
- Gallery: Nine jobs that humans may lose to robots
- Robots get their own encyclopedia
Alan Boyle is NBCNews.com's science editor. Connect with the Cosmic Log community by "liking" the log's Facebook page, following @b0yle on Twitter and adding the Cosmic Log page to your Google+ presence. To keep up with Cosmic Log as well as NBCNews.com's other stories about science and space, sign up for the Tech & Science newsletter, delivered to your email in-box every weekday. You can also check out "The Case for Pluto," my book about the controversial dwarf planet and the search for new worlds.


Where is R2-D2, C-3PO, Robbie the Robot, the B9 Robot from Lost in Space. It seems to me that you have left out the best. Sorry can't vote.
Robert, R2-D2, C-3PO and Robby were inducted into the Hall of Fame already, as noted above, so they have their place in the pantheon. B-9, however, has not been honored (yet), and so I'll take your observation as a vote for B9 in the People's Choice awards. (B9 was the Cosmic Log People's Choice in 2006):
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12359455/ns/technology_and_science-science/t/cosmic-log-robo-winner/
I must add my vote for the Lost in Space robot. The voice is still with me today from early childhood. I was impressed and gratified that at least a reasonable facsimile of it was included in the later movie version.
DANGER WILL ROBINSON, DANGER.
It was a toss up for me, the cool and cuddly Johnny 5 from one of my favorite movies or the adorable Wall-e. I went with Wall-e. I think it was the eyes.
But definitely the Lost In Space robot (from the original TV series) is a must.
I'm also assuming GORT from the original THE DAY THE EARTH STOOD STILL is also already an inductee?
How about BENDER ("Kiss my shiny butt!") from FUTURAMA? Surely he has been honored.
OMG I would have voted for Bender! Or Data - Data better already be in the hall of fame!
Bender, Bender, Bender.
Bender Bending Rodrigues
also "DANGER WILL ROBINSON, MY ARMS ARE FLAILING"
Weeeelllll, Data isn't technically a robot. He's an android, or "artificial human" as he prefers to be called.
Ya. the "bubble headed booby" from lost in space should be on the list but it was obviously fashioned after Robbie. Also HAL 9000 was just as much robot as computer, wasn't it?
Nice to see that some down below remembered Mystery Science Theater bots, Kryton from Red Dwarf and Marvin from the Hitchhiker series. But also from Douglas Adams, what about electric monks?
I don't see Fembots, the mechanical "dagget" Muffit from the original Battlestar Galactica series (1970's), or Twiki from Buck Rogers.
Is Westworld mentioned anywhere? What about Cherry 2000?
Anyone read the Blue Adept series, with the robots wanting equal rights?
Personally, I voted for a real robot, but I do love the ones on the big and small screen and in the pages. I'm sure I'll remember more after I post this.
Yep, I remember more.
Mecha Godzilla, Mecha Ghidora, Mecha Kong, Mecha Mothra, Jet Jaquar,...
I am disappointed Packbot isn't winning. I understand the emotional connection to Hollywood characters, but figured that a robot that is saving the lives of Americas best and innocent civilians would be doing better.
Also, haven't found any references to R. Daneel Olivaw from Foundation series!
hey what about K-9 from doctor who?
Oh, and honorable mention, but not winners, to the kid in AI and Robin Williams character in Centennial Man. Good, but not winners. Also, does anyone remember Black Hole? A Disney movie with robots that came out about the time of Star Trek: The Motion Picture? Good robots, but not great.
Oh, and some great robots, the ones from Silent Running. Good movie (I need to find that).
I almost forgot about Box from Logan's Run.
Where's K-9, Doctor Who's robot dog?
Meh. Tom Baker didn't even like K-9
He eventually is very fond of K-9, i'd vote for K-9 and for bender! But i picked Johnny 5 over wall-e even though i absolutely adore wall-e cuz i figured no one remembered 'number 5 is alive!', what a great film
No disassasemble Johnny 5!!
anybody who didnt vote for Johnny 5 might get a viset from Los Lobos soon.
Bah to all of these. There hasn't been a decent robot since Robbie nearly melted down due to his Prime Directive.
Johnny Sako Robot, Marvin the Paranoid Android, Gort, Tom Servo, Crow T. Robot, Gypsy, Twiki, are some missed.
You mean those obnoxious robots that sit in the "peanut gallery" while watching cheezy sci-fi? :) wink wink.
Where's Clank? Ratchet and Clank's tiny little hero robot surely deserves a place among these folks.
I agree, R2-D2 would always be on the top of the list if included but that robot is already in the Robot Hall of Fame which is why that robot is not included in the list. For those wondering where some robots are, make sure to read the article as this is the current nomination list, not the greatest of all time as many are already in the Robot Hall of Fame.
I grew up with Johnny 5, which most kids probably cannot identify with so they choose Wall-E instead. However, having observed them for the first time together, I can't help but notice the similarities between Johnny 5 and Wall-E...both have the same type of triangular tank treads, the heads are similar, and if I recall, both had somewhat interchangeable parts...so I have to go with the one that inspired the other.
However, movie robots should not really be compared to research robots because while movie robots are cool, for the most part, they are just remote controlled and do not run totally autonomously. However, a robot like the Big Dog is real and it responds to the environment (or impacts) without any input from a controller. That makes this robot truly groundbreaking and what the future will become. Plus, it is really the first robot that kind of creeped me out when I first saw it as I really wish they put a head on it.
I see that ClapTrap is missing from this list. I want to see claptrap and wall-e go toe-to-toe.. that would be entertaining.
What kid wouldn't want his own Lost-in-Space B9 Robot protecting him???
Right on! They so forgot Robot from Lost in Space!!! I grew up on that robot.
K9 was cool, almost as cool as r2-d2, but, alas, robbie was more popular on all continents. Of course, a bunch of star trek robots are missing. Also a bunch of current MIT robots are missing....but once they put max head room on wheels, watch out. I figure most of the ones listed in the article still have some sort of residuals and a good story will bring all of them some clams, one way or another. But the unsung heros of today are a slew of unmanned drones, some with enough AI to delinate terms of engagement, in miltary terms that is, and act upon it's own decisions. I originally thought JEDEC forbid such a machine, but have come to find out, not so. If a robot can detect a threat to itself or humans, it can nuetralize that threat, no permission needed if it can ascertain that it is another machine it is destroying....I'll leave it at that for now.
KRYTEN from Red Dwarf!! :)
oh yea!!!
We need a movie with Kryton from Red Dwarf and Marvin from the Heart of Gold in the Hitchhiker series somehow ending up on a ship together.
How curious that a cute robot type article appears the day following the Sunday NY Times front page story about super robots displacing millions of workers and the technology advancing so that in the future, there will be no job they can't perform! Robots are not cute, they are the ultimate "scab", and an affront to common decency and the working man or women throughout the whole world. Corporate profits benefit a few rich elitists at the humiliation and expense of most everyone else in the world. I have yet to see armored cars following a hearse so the deceased can take it with them. But how you got all that wealth, and what you did with it, may be of great interest to God.
Yes, that's an interesting and scary article. Here it is:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/19/business/new-wave-of-adept-robots-is-changing-global-industry.html?pagewanted=all
Mike Royko wrote an article around 25 years ago concerning automation in the work place. The article pointed out the folly of this trend at the end when the head robot of a tennis shoe factory came into the owners office with a box of tennis shoes, and asked the boss where it should put them. The boss said put it into the warehouse, what's the matter with you. The robot replied that the warehouse was full. The boss replied; what, how can this be, why aren't the shoes selling. The robot replied; don't ask me, I don't wear tennis shoes.
And now Cisco Systems is building robots that can fix themsleves. I guess that the geniuses at the top of the corporate world should probably reconsider automation as an alternative to human labor unless they can figure out how to include robots into the financial transaction known as supply and demand. All of the efficiently produced supply in the world will do you no good if there is no demand because of the lack of funds to purchase such efficiently produced supply.
I think that "Big Blue" would do a better job of running corporate America then those over stuffed buffoons sitting in the front offices anyway.
you forgot one of the greatest! R. Daneel Olivaw from Isaac Asimov. probably the insperation for many of the later ones
Yes! Asimov's R. Daneel Olivaw certainly deserves a place in the RHOF. Formulating the Zeroth Law of Robotics was genius, and he thus acted as a protector of humanity.
Johnny 5 should make it before Wall-E.
Bender? Where is Bender? Foul mouth, cigar smoking robot; come on!
Bender? Where is Bender the foul mouth, cigar smoking robot?
Yeah, Bender.
Or the most human looking robot invented in our time. Sure it's has been plagued with bugs such as not properly imitating human facial expressions, but dammit why isn't Keanu Reeves on this list?
Bender indeed... I hear he is 40% Robot!
Has everyone forgotten the Master Cylinder? Looked like a 55 gal drum with one wheel....Or is it because he was a bad guy?
Otherwise, Bender will do nicely.
B-9 from Lost in Space (after all his name is "Robot"),
and/or R. Daneel Olivaw (guardian of all mankind if you're read ALL the Foundation sequels).
Stand up for great robot, even if he says so himself Bender. Kiss my shiny metal azz!
Those robots are too cute! kiss my shiny meta as*! OHH whats the point in living if i cant say AS*!!!